Understanding the Hidden Pain of Pastors: A Call for Compassion

Leston Blackburn
Oct 9
3 min read

Updated: Oct 30

In the quiet corners of ministry, behind pulpits and pastoral smiles, there exists a seldom-spoken reality: some pastors are suffering—not just from burnout or spiritual dryness, but from abuse at the hands of the very churches and leadership structures they serve.

While much attention has rightly been given to abuse perpetrated by pastors, a growing body of evidence reveals that spiritual leaders themselves are often victims of verbal, emotional, and even physical mistreatment. In a striking article by Premier Christianity, one evangelical leader described being afraid to open emails due to the barrage of criticism and hostility from congregants and leadership alike: “The shouting, the physical abuse, the WhatsApp messages, the accusations, the judgement—I thought: This isn’t OK” [1].

The Insidious Nature of Spiritual Abuse

This form of spiritual abuse is insidious. It often masquerades as “accountability” or “correction,” yet it leaves pastors isolated, disempowered, and questioning their calling.

Abuse may come in various forms, including:

Constant criticism or undermining of leadership decisions
Manipulative control over pastoral duties or preaching content
Public shaming or gossip within the congregation
Withholding of salary or resources
Emotional coercion masked as spiritual concern

Danny Slavich, writing for the Centre for Pastor Theologians, notes that for every story of a pastor misusing power, there are many more of pastors being abused by congregants or leadership teams. These stories include pastors returning from sabbatical to find they’ve been dismissed or being ghosted by those they’ve faithfully served [2].

Dr Merethe Dahl Turner, in her analysis for the Lausanne Movement, highlights how blurred boundaries between authority and friendship in ministry settings can enable abuse—especially when churches lack clear safeguarding policies for adults [3].

A Word to the Wounded

If you are a pastor who has been abused by your church or leadership, hear this: your pain is real, and it matters. You are not weak for feeling weary. You are not faithless for needing help. You are not alone.

Jesus, the Good Shepherd, was rejected by His own. He understands. And we, as your brothers and sisters in Christ, stand ready to walk with you—not to fix you, but to remind you of the One who never forsakes.

How We Can Help

How can Discipleship Foundation help? For pastors who have been hurt by the church, we offer:

Confidential, Spirit-led support: Our resources and conversations are designed to be safe, hope-filled, and spiritually nourishing.
Encouragement through restoration: Our heart is to help pastors and ministry leaders rediscover their identity in Christ, apart from titles or roles.
Online course: Whether you're seeking clarity, comfort, or community, our materials are crafted to uplift without overwhelming. Explore our online course - Called, Broken, Beloved - it is an eight-module recovery journey for ministry leaders and church members healing from Church harm.
A listening ear: We understand the pain of being misunderstood, silenced, or spiritually manipulated. You are not alone.

We do not rush healing. We would be honoured to walk gently and prayerfully with you, offering space for reflection, lament, and renewal.

Called, Broken, Beloved Online Course

The Importance of Community Support

In times of distress, the support of a community can be invaluable. It is essential to find a safe space where you can express your feelings without fear of judgement. Connecting with others who understand your journey can provide comfort and encouragement.

Building Trusting Relationships

Building trusting relationships within a supportive community is vital. Look for groups or individuals who share your faith and values. These connections can help you feel less isolated and more understood.

Seeking Professional Guidance

Sometimes, professional guidance can be beneficial. A therapist or counselor who understands the unique challenges faced by pastors can offer tools and strategies for healing. They can help you navigate the complexities of your experiences and emotions.

Embracing Healing and Restoration

Healing is a journey, not a destination. It takes time and patience. Embrace the process, allowing yourself to feel and reflect.

Finding Hope in Scripture

Scripture offers profound wisdom and comfort. Verses that speak of God’s love, mercy, and healing can provide strength during difficult times. Meditate on these passages, allowing them to seep into your heart and mind.

Practicing Self-Care

Self-care is not selfish; it is essential. Prioritise activities that nourish your spirit and body. Whether it’s spending time in nature, engaging in creative pursuits, or simply resting, allow yourself the grace to recharge.

Conclusion: A Journey Towards Wholeness

As we navigate the complexities of ministry, let us remember that we are not alone. Together, we can foster a culture of compassion and understanding. Let us support one another in our journeys towards healing and wholeness.

References: